Review Home Page

Submission Introduction

DVA Request For submissions

VEA s 4A

Non Publication Computer Code

Non Application High Court Precedents

Writeway Reports ultra vires

Minister Has Authority to Make Decisions

Claims Redetermined After Ultra Vires

Referral Diagnosis Precedent to High Court

Consent Declaration

Researcher Instructions

Referral of Federal Court Precedent (requiring diagnosis before Deledio process) to High Court.

Precedent is clearly wrong and has never been to High Court – Five out of five decisions by High Court have gone against Repatriation Commission. An easy way to demonstrate Federal Court Precedent is wrong is to apply Federal Court Precedent to facts of Byrnes case. In other words use VEA sec 120(4) instead of VEA sec 120(1). Federal Court Precedent then overturns Byrnes decision. Obviously this is wrong because a lower court (Federal Court) cannot overrule a higher court (High Court).